This database contains full message text and selected message information for all of the messages in the Transgender Usenet Archive. To read a message, please enter the unique numerical identifier, or Message ID, in the search box below. If you plan to read multiple messages, you may wish to keep both the archive and this database open in separate tabs.

 

Message

Message ID 365969
Sender David Weinshenker
Original or Reply Original
Date Posted 11-19-1999
Newsgroups Posted To soc.support.transgendered
Post Subject Line feminine muscle growth patterns
Message Text
Quoted from Jennifer Diane Reitz on http://transsexuality.org
    - - --- beginquote --- - -
  Q: "When estrogen is taken, it results in muscle loss. 
  I can understand that. But what I want to know is if it 
  relates to a ratio, or if there's a decrease that is more 
  or less constant. As in does it drop to a certain pre-defined 
  level or does it drop unconditionally?..."

  Women have not only less muscle mass, on average, than men, they 
  have different muscle distribution as well. Males have more of 
  the thick and bulky fibrous 'power' muscles that are high in 
  strength, but low in agility, while women -on average- have 
  more of the thin and delicate smooth 'dexterity' muscles that 
  provide precise control. When estrogen runs the biochemical means 
  of production, not only fat cell distribution, skin, and 
  neurochemistry is altered, but also the distribution of the type 
  and kind of muscle cells. 

  Under estrogen smooth muscles begin to dominate, over time, and 
  the total muscle mass shrinks to a level relative to overall body 
  mass and skeletal structure equivalent to that you would have if 
  you had been born female to begin with.
    - - --- endquote --- - -

Hmmm... I've seen some reports by M->F estrogen users that they
have improved skill at "dexterity" sports (golf, tennis,
catching things, etc.): Perhaps this is another confirmation
of the "brain sex/gendermap wiring" theory. Once muscle tissue
growth has been estrogenized, one finally has the body one's
brain was wired to control. 

This may have something to do with the experience many have
had of being told that they "XXX like a girl" (XXX=run, walk, 
throw, etc.)... I've never been good at throwing, and have been 
told that I "do it like a girl"... perhaps if I took estrogen
and obtained a good description of what the difference between 
"throwing like a girl" and "throwing like a guy" actually is,
and then tried to practice "throwing like a girl", I'd be better
at throwing. (That's been one of the few "like-a-girl" reactions
that I've actually tended to get.)

 -dave w